1
USDA Forest Service Res. Note RMRSRN6. 1999
A Preliminary Hazard Model of White Pine
Blister Rust for the Sacramento Ranger
District, Lincoln National Forest
Brian W. Geils1, David A. Conklin2, and Eugene P. Van Arsdel3
United States
Department of
Agriculture
Forest Service
Rocky Mountain
Research Station
Research Note
RMRSRN6
August 1999
AbstractBlister rust, caused by the introduced
fungus Cronartium ribicola, is a serious disease of
white pines in North America. Since about 1970, an
outbreak has been increasing in the Sacramento
Mountains of southern New Mexico and threatens
southwestern white pine. To help determine the
expected extent and impact of blister rust, we pro-
pose a preliminary hazard model for the Sacra-
mento Ranger District. The model is based on field
observations and experience. We assume blister
rust incidence and severity on white pine varies
with microclimate and proximity to telial hosts
(certain species of Ribes). We identify the sites at
risk and rank them into three relative hazard classes
based on elevation, plant association, and topo-
graphic position. Information is currently avail-
able to provisionally identify hazard for blister rust
on 35% of the district area at risk. Of the area rated,
12% is low hazard, 43% is moderate hazard, and
45% is high hazard. Average rust incidence level
for plots rated as low, moderate, or high hazard
was 6%, 45%, and 47%, respectively; average sever-
ity was 0.1, 2.5, and 4.5 cankers per tree. Studies are
underway to test and refine the model.
Keywords: Cronartium ribicola, southwestern white
pine, Pinus strobiformis
Introduction
White pine blister rust, Cronartium ribicola J. C.
Fisch., is an introduced pathogen to North America
where it causes serious economic and ecological
damage to white pines (Ziller 1974). The fungus
has a complex life cycle of alternating spore stages
between white pines (section Strobus, aecial hosts),
where it causes perennial cankers, and currents or
gooseberries (Ribes, telial hosts), where it causes a
foliage disease.
Since the initial report of the disease in the
Sacramento Mountains of southern New Mexico
(Hawksworth 1990), the rust has been found
throughoutmostoftherangeofsouthwesternwhite
pine (Pinus strobiformis Engelm.) in the Sacramento
and adjoining White Mountains. This area includes
the Sacramento Ranger District (RD), much of the
Smokey Bear RD, and the Mescalero Apache In-
dian Reservation. Based on the apparent age of
cankers, the rust first became established around
1970 on the west side of the Sacramento Mountains.
After remaining at relatively low levels for several
years, a major expansion occurred around 1985
(Hawksworth and Conklin 1990, Conklin 1994,
Van Arsdel and others 1998). Since then, there have
been several years in which significant numbers of
new infections have occurred on pine. In 1994,
infected pines were found in the Capitan Moun-
tains (Smokey Bear RD), an isolated range about 30
miles north of the main outbreak area (Conklin and
Schultz, 1999, personal communication). In 1999,
two infected white pines were found on Gallinas
Peak (Cibola National Forest), about 50 miles north
of the Capitan Mountains (Van Arsdel and Conklin,
1999,personalcommunication).Othernearbypopu-
lations of white pine at risk are on the San Mateo
and Magdalena Mountains.
1
Research Plant Pathologist with the Rocky Mountain
Research Station, Flagstaff, Arizona.
2
Plant Pathologist with the Southwestern Region, Albu-
querque, New Mexico.
3
Retired Plant Pathologist and volunteer with the Rocky
Mountain Research Station, Flagstaff, Arizona.